Today Manchester United appointed Mauricio Pochettino as head coach. I wish him well. He’s a good coach and a decent man. But I fear we’ve changed the wrong person. Again.
Everybody has a view on who’s to blame for what’s going wrong at Old Trafford. Mine is a little different. I don’t think it’s one person. I think it’s the structure, and what that structure does to people.
It’s not a business. It’s a game.
The men who own football clubs today are, by and large, very successful businessmen. So they do what they know. They run their club like one of their businesses. A chief executive. A director of football. Layers of management in between.
Now, there is a business side to a football club, and that should be run as a business. The commercial deals, the stadium, the money. Fine. But the football side is different. It’s a game. A game that generates revenue, yes, but a game. And you cannot run a game like a business.
Who sees the training pitch?
Think about what a director of football actually sees. He goes to every match. Saturday afternoon, Sunday afternoon. But he isn’t on the training ground every day. He doesn’t feel the psychology of the players. He doesn’t feel their hunger. He doesn’t see what’s missing on a wet Tuesday morning at Carrington.
So he watches a game and thinks, we need a better right winger. Off he goes and finds one. Meanwhile the manager, who is with those players every single day, wanted something completely different.
And here’s the psychology of it. When things go wrong, somebody has to go. The director of football doesn’t want to lose his job. Neither does the chief executive. So who gets thrown under the bus? The manager. Every time. They’ll tell you their long-term visions are aligned. They are, right up until somebody has to carry the can.
Michael Carrick deserved better
Look at what Michael Carrick did. He came in at the beginning of the year and won 12 of his 17 games, beat City 2–0, and took us back into the Champions League. The players played for him. You could see it.
Then the summer came, and around £155 million was spent on four players. With respect to Youri Tielemans — a good player — he isn’t a Manchester United midfielder. Not the United that Carrick played in. That United had Roy Keane and Paul Scholes in the middle of the park. Carrick was trying to rebuild that. He didn’t get the tools to do it.
Lisandro Martínez said it out loud in October, after Madrid. He expected “more from the top, from upstairs.” More from the technical director. When a senior player says that in public, believe me, the dressing room has already said it in private.
A month later, it’s Carrick who’s gone. Not the people upstairs.
Back to basics
So what does a football club really need? Let’s go back to basics.
You need an owner — ideally the chairman — who works directly with his manager. Not hearing it second-hand from somebody who’s conflicted and has his own agenda. Everybody can see what happens on a Saturday. The owner should come in, look at his biggest asset, and work with the man running it.
You need a manager in total control of the first team, who decides how the team plays and what type of player fits. Not “he’s quick, he can dribble, he’ll do.” Not a six-foot-seven centre forward when the manager wants a nippy five-foot-eight one.
You need a chief scout who answers to the manager. That’s how Sir Alex did it. He had his own scouts, he had the backing of his chairman, and he kept a close eye on the youth team. So he knew exactly what type of player he needed, and so did everyone else, from top to bottom.
And you need everybody singing off the same hymn sheet, from the under-nines to the first team. Look at Barcelona. Before Johan Cruyff, they’d never won the European Cup. Cruyff made every team at the club play the same way, with the same drills, the same type of player in every position. They won it in 1992, and the same system gave the world Xavi, Iniesta and Messi. Teach them all the same, and they’re far more likely to fit when their time comes.
“But Liverpool had a sporting director”
I know. Jürgen Klopp worked with Michael Edwards and won everything. But that worked because the two of them agreed on almost everything, and the owners backed their manager. That’s rare. At most clubs, the man in the middle becomes a second power base with a second agenda.
And look at Abramovich and Mourinho. Their best years were when the owner backed his manager directly. When did it go wrong? When Abramovich started picking players himself. Owner and manager, close together, each doing his own job. That’s the trick.
Sir Jim, here’s what I’d have done
You promised us best in class, Sir Jim. I think you missed a trick.
I’d have backed Michael Carrick and changed the structure above him instead. I’d have stood up and said: I’m going to work closely with my manager. These players were excellent for him in the spring. We’ll get him the players he wants, players who suit the way he wants to play. He’ll oversee the scouting and the academy, and he’ll report to me.
That would have empowered the whole club. And those players would have run through a brick wall for him.Instead, the manager’s gone and the structure stays. Pochettino is a fine coach. But unless the people above him change the way they work, I fear we’ll be having this same conversation in eighteen months’ time.
Sir Jim, get close to your manager. That’s the trick you missed.
These are my own views, as a lifelong United fan and someone who has run a football club. Tell me where you think I’m wrong. Angelo Luiz-Barrea